All the Sinners Bleed: Race, Racism, Religion, and Family | Anshul Patel

In the annals of Charon County, Virginia, Titus Crown stands as the inaugural Black sheriff, carving history with distinction. Charon, seemingly a bastion of rustic simplicity with its moonshine, cornbread, and honeysuckle ambiance, has, however, concealed beneath its veneer a tapestry of clandestine narratives—a truth well-known to Titus, an ex-FBI operative.

Exactly a year post Titus's election, the tranquility is shattered as a schoolteacher falls prey to a former pupil, met with a fatal response from Titus's deputies. Amidst the ensuing investigation, Titus unravels a sinister web of crimes and exposes a lurking serial killer, camouflaged in the byways and clearings of Charon. With potential ties to a local church and the town's tumultuous history casting shadows, Titus grapples to project assurance in closing the case, all while safeguarding a poignant secret from his own past. Simultaneously, he contends with a far-right faction seeking to orchestrate a parade commemorating the town's Confederate legacy.

Charon, both Titus's domicile and heart, stands at the crossroads of faith and violence, awaiting a moment of retribution.

It comes as no surprise to witness an S.A. Cosby narrative securing a prominent slot on my "Best Books of the Year" catalog. Blacktop Wasteland claimed the apex in 2020, and Razorblade Tears secured a commendable fourth spot in 2021. Anticipation for All the Sinners Bleed was met with not just fulfillment but surpassing expectations.

Much like Cosby's preceding works, All the Sinners Bleed unfolds in the rural expanse of eastern Virginia, specifically the fictional Charon County. Inhabitants, rooted in the county for lifetimes, rarely encounter strangers. Sheriff Titus Crown, the narrative's focal figure, managed to escape Charon's clutches, acquiring education from UVA and Columbia. His sojourn with the FBI preceded his return prompted by familial obligations and a challenging case. Elected as sheriff, Titus endeavors to maintain order as the inaugural Black occupant of the position, facing the community's tentative acceptance.

S.A. Cosby

S.A. Cosby, hailing from Southeastern Virginia, has earned acclaim as a New York Times national best-selling and award-winning author. Notably, his literary repertoire encompasses works like "My Darkest Prayer," "Blacktop Wasteland," and the highly lauded "Razorblade Tears."

"Blacktop Wasteland" garnered substantial recognition, securing the coveted title of Amazon's #1 Mystery and Thriller of the Year in 2020. It further clinched the position as the #3 Best Book of the year overall, attaining the status of a New York Times Notable Book of the Year and earning distinction as a New York Times Book Review Editors’ Choice. The novel also emerged victorious at the LA Times Book Award for Mystery or Thrillers, securing a place as a Goodreads Choice Awards Semifinalist. Impressively, it received the ITW Award for Hardcover Book of the Year, the Macavity for Best Novel of the Year, and the Anthony. Additionally, it garnered recognition from The Barry and an honorable mention from the ALA Black Caucus. It stood as a finalist for the CWA Golden Dagger, solidifying its place in the literary pantheon.

S.A. Cosby's follow-up work, "Razorblade Tears," continued his streak of success, garnering nominations for various prestigious awards.

Beyond novels, Cosby has made a mark in the realm of short fiction. His stories, including "Slant-Six," have found a home in numerous anthologies and magazines. The accolades continued with his short story "The Grass Beneath My Feet," which earned him the Anthony Award for Best Short Story in 2019.

Critics have showered praise on Cosby's writing, describing it as "gritty and heartbreaking," "dark, thrilling, and tragic," and "raw, emotional, and profound." His literary contributions stand as a testament to his ability to craft narratives that resonate with depth, emotion, and an undeniable impact on readers.
The tale commences with a sadly familiar occurrence—a school shooting. A revered teacher succumbs, and the assailant meets a swift demise at the hands of Titus's deputies. This incident serves as the portal into the primary plot and mystery. The teacher, the assailant, and a third figure, dubbed "The Last Wolf," harbored unspeakable transgressions involving Charon's children. While two lie deceased, one still roams, compelling Sheriff Crown to embark on a personal crusade against The Last Wolf.

Despite initial concerns of Cosby embracing a formulaic approach, All the Sinners Bleed stands distinct from its predecessors. Opting for a lawman as the central character, especially a Black one, adds layers to the narrative. Though not delving fully into the intricacies of law enforcement and the Black community, the novel broaches the subject through a character grappling with internal conflicts.

Cosby, unflinching in addressing contentious themes, intertwines race relations and sharp observations on religion. Titus Crown, shaped by Cosby, echoes the author's skepticism toward organized religion. Having witnessed its darker facets in his upbringing, Crown vehemently rejects God, offering a unique exploration of faith, belief, and a transformation over time.

The mystery unfolds meticulously, with Cosby's trademark character depth and societal commentary elevating the narrative. A tightly woven story, it manages to transcend genre conventions, standing out as a remarkable mystery. Amidst the bleak crimes, Cosby injects glimmers of hope and goodness, showcasing the dichotomy of human nature.

Ranking it against the year's offerings, it eclipses even Dennis Lehane's Small Mercies, holding the coveted top spot on my "Best Books of 2023 So Far" roster. The overlap in themes with Lehane's work, specifically on race relations, adds resonance. However, All the Sinners Bleed introduces an extra layer of nuance to the mystery, coupled with a more convincingly portrayed main character, making it my current pinnacle of literary exploration in 2023.

Cosby's narrative prowess continues with a riveting portrayal of an anti-hero sheriff, a man confronting his past and striving to navigate the complexities of his present. All the Sinners Bleed unveils a harrowing cascade of events triggered by a school shooting, exposing child abuse and a lurking serial killer. In true Cosby fashion, the characters, though diverse in roles, share a common thread—an anti-hero wrestling with guilt and regret.

The overarching themes of race, racism, religion, and family permeate the narrative, painted against the canvas of heinous crimes. Sheriff Titus Crown, summoned to a high school besieged by an active shooter, grapples not only with external threats but also with internal demons from his past in a distant law enforcement job. Cosby's novel offers a fast-paced, immersive reading experience, characterized by sickening violence, moral ambiguity, and a relentless pursuit of justice.

All the Sinners Bleed stands testament to Cosby's ability to tackle live-wire issues, incorporating race relations and delivering pointed critiques on organized religion. Titus Crown's rejection of faith, shaped by personal tragedies and a nuanced exploration of scripture, adds depth to the narrative. While Cosby typically presents multifaceted perspectives, this novel leans into a more unequivocal stance on religion, portraying it as a scourge through Crown's disillusioned lens.

Navigating a complex tapestry of mystery, character introspection, and societal commentary, All the Sinners Bleed is a compelling addition to Cosby's body of work. Though the abundance of characters and layers may challenge some readers, the raw simplicity of his earlier books is missed by those accustomed to his earlier, more straightforward narratives. Nevertheless, the novel remains a thought-provoking, intricate exploration of human nature and societal dynamics in the rural South.

BUY Your Copy